Game Theory: The Mystery of Minecraft's Haunted Discs (Minecraft)

Pubblicato il 15 ago 2019
Get Your New Back To School Theory Wear Here!! ►
Today Theorists, I aim to solve another one of the many mysteries of Minecraft. We've explored a lot already, but with a game this big, there is always more to find. Take the music discs, which are the objects you find randomly throughout the game when you do certain things. Except, there are two discs in particular that peaked my interest - Disc 11 and Disc 13. The two "corrupted" discs that, when you play them, sound like something from a horror game rather than Minecraft. What is going on with Discs 11 and 13? Let's find out!
SUBSCRIBE for More Theories! ►
Get the game here ►►
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ►
SUBSCRIBE for Every Theory! ►►
Hang out with us on GTLive! ►
#Minecraft #Enderman #Disc11 #Disc13 #Corrupted #Haunted #MinecraftTheory #Theory #GameTheory
The TRUTH About MINECRAFT’s World! ►►
The END of Princess Peach! ►
Minecraft's Ending, DECODED! ►►
Mario Kart 8, Mario's SCARIEST Game? ►
What's Diamond Armor Worth IRL? ►►
Writers: Matthew Patrick
Editors: BanditRants, Tyler Mascola, Dan "Cybert" Seibert, and Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman


  • and who would've known that the sweet tunes I was cranking in my epic base held so much hidden lore

  • Lol after this video I was kinda scared to go into caves. HECK even play Minecraft (am big baby lol)

  • I've got a theory. What if at the end of music discs 13 and 11, the miner underground does not escape the cave instead he is attacked and his body is possessed by an enderman. Now this raises another question. How are the endermen in the overworld? I feel that some of the endermen thought that if they jumped into the void of the end, they would die and respawn as their human forms again. Some of the endermen attempted to do this, and they were killed and teleported back into the overworld, however they do not regain their human form, and are still endermen. This would also explain why endermen basically stalk the player and try to distract them, so they can possess that human form and be normal again. Anyway back to the basic theory at hand. I believe that this guy who had his body possessed by an endermen had his soul and dna seperate from him. That soul of his and his dna was taken by the two entities you encounter at the end of the game and create the player character, Steve. The guy who is possessed by the endermen becomes herobrine. HEAR ME OUT. Herobrine stalks the player from a distance and teleports when the player gets too close to him, he also looks the same as steve, with the only difference being his white eyes, and the final piece of the puzzle. The original miner's name could be anyone, nicholas, mark, or even steve. But the endermen's past name was herobrine, before he became an endermen. And the player probably just gave himself the name "steve" because why not. My final piece of the theory is herobrine is in a human body again, but the miner's soul and herobrine's human soul are combined to form steve, And herobrine wants his soul back. So he hunts steve down until he is ready to attack him and kill him.

  • Hello my fellow miners and crafters- Scar Game theory uses same thing, me: :0

  • *sees thumbnail* Me:wait! That's illegal!

  • FNAF got nothing on minecraft

  • Me: *sees thumbnail Creeper: *has arms Also me: wait that's illegal

  • what if the person in disc 11 and 13 retreated to the cave to get away from the wither?

  • Warning: This video is kinda spoopy. 7/10 on the spoopymeter.

  • 10:30 You don't hear the second arrow land, but you do hear the sound that used to happen when you'd take damage. I believe that it is safe to assume that the person in the cave was hit by an arrow before encountering the creeper


  • Wait Humans in Minecraft...Does that Mean that Minecraft VR is the prequel to Minecraft?

  • Screamer in the intro. Not cool.

  • what if the person in the audio was actually a real person in real life from the future that got trapped in a minecraft cave

  • What if we survived the attack and woke up in the woods with amnesia, which is why we have a small library of what we can. Build even before having a crafting table

  • How did they get the disc were they use to be something more advance also or is it created inside of them?

  • Welp, I’m not sleeping tonight

  • hello Mathew Patric and the Game Theories team, i really love the way you analyzing and link things between each other and even how you see things neutrally without having any bias towards any side, and without mentioning the scientific facts you bring along, it really strengthen your point of view, and i was a fan of you back in 2016-2017-2018 and i have learned A LOT from you, and i want to thank you for all the work you do, and by the subject of Disc 13 and Disc 11 i first listened to them and got scared a bit, but i didn't pay too much attention to them, unlike you lol.... and i just knew that there could be information in audio files, that's a new information for me, thank you a lot Mathew

  • Disksksksksksksksk and I oop and I oop sksksksks

  • Video: oooh I’m gonna cut to black in so spoooookyyyy!!! My reflection: :|

  • Okie I get the ancient ppl part but... Where do u "the player" Fit in, in this world. How do u not remember the ancient builders, where did u come from? I mean we are the same species right?

  • Why can’t you cure normal zombies

  • i have a theory the cave sounds are noise off dead pepole talking to you

  • ...awwwwww man

  • I'm sure most of you probably had that exact same experience *Flashback starts*

  • You are ruining Minecraft's innocence with those theories


  • Wheres 1-10 and 12?

  • Creeper. Aw Men!

  • You’re overlooking the enderman sounds and dog barking at the end of disc 11

  • When creepers get assassinated by skeletons they drop their disstrack.

  • creeper awwww man

  • There's a secret code in that notebook

  • Herobrine was just a myth it was in the removed in the updates as a joke it was never added they just said it was removed it was originally a creepy pasta

  • I don't like disc 11.

  • What if herobrine is a builder turning into an enderman or just didn't transform fully

    • Then he became a enderman that's why he doesn't appear anymore

  • Maybe the disks discribed Nicholas before he became herobrine, I guess it could make sence.

  • Hey, do theories on the -Cave sounds -Ambient music -Creepers -Mushroom land

  • the real question is why do ALL creepers have this information physically ingrained in them? Until we know that, the question of the place of creepers in the lore has not been fully answered.

  • 36

  • Got some release dates wrong, Matpat. Disk 11 was added in the 1.9 prerelease; compasses and maps were already in.

  • That is not "dirt" walking (SFX).. its eating something (SFX).. i think

  • Perhaps the player is Nicholas or the miner in the disks who has lost his memory and must redescover the history of his people.

  • What do you Mean the story was not scary herobrian scard me SILL when I was your age

  • Maybe disc 11 is one on the ancient humans trapped in the end turning into a Ender man wile escaping back to the real world however they end up turning in the world and now endermen walk the over world

  • matpat knows how to scare me

  • the original people in minecraft got thanos'd

  • at the end of disc 11 when it cuts out you can hear a wolf dying in minecraft

  • When you’re birthday is on the 13th.....

  • Lol MCEU could be Minecraft or Marvel Comics

  • Have you ever wondered why Enderman take random blocks? Are they building something? If so, what are they building and what is its purpose?

  • Maybe the disc 11 is actually in the nether. The heavy breathing is from the fire and smoke, the stone sound might be nethertack and the dirt sound is someone on gravel, both blocks mostly fpind on the nether. But maybe the discs 11 and 13 ARE connected and after going into a cave getting blow up by a creeper, gets obsidian, and puts it into a portal and lights it with the metallic sound you heard...flint and steel. Then when the disc cuts off your in the nether, and the paper you heard was recording thiere thoughts. Or the end of 11 is the wither killing its target. After the person summoned it with the supplies, curious.

  • Pewdiepies giant meatball XD

  • 5:55 I thought I was gunna get Rick Rolled

  • 12:49 I dont feel like it would be more of "Dans realm" because he practically abounded his Minecraft and his custom mode adventures just so he would get more money from FartNut.

  • You can get discs from chests

  • Heard about the minecart crash theory?

  • the NETHER is hell, if you look at soul sand closely You can see what look like screaming faces. These could be souls of the departed who were trapped together to make a block. This would also explain why soul sand slows you down, it could be that you are the only living thing in the NETHER, and the souls want you to join them in the sand. The souls tug on you, trying to pull you into the sand and there for slow you down. The zombie pigmen are just dead pigs and the ghasts are dead people who maybe died incredibly depressed or died to join another close person who died, hence the tears. The wither is the God of this underworld. The wither skeletons are skeletons who feast on souls. When a wither skeleton hits you your health turns black and slowly drains, this is because they are trying to drain your soul. Maybe they are people who were drained by the wither and try to become 'whole' by draining the souls of others to replenish there own lost soul.

  • That's all cool and all, but mat! *Where's Disc 12?*

  • Dude ya need to do a granny video. GRANNY